Case Study Drop
Issue #40
2025-04-14
6 min read

How a 6-Person Leadership Team Was Making 89% of All Decisions

A $28M professional services firm had a CTO making 89% of decisions — including which color to use in a client deck. Here's the 30-day structural intervention that freed up 22 hours per week of founder bandwidth.

PP
Patrick Precourt
Founder, Business Performance Engineering
MON Scribe
How a 6-Person Leadership Team Was Making 89% of All Decisions

The Discovery

The CTO of a $28M professional services firm was making 89% of all decisions in the company. Not strategic decisions. All decisions.

Including which color to use in a client presentation deck. Including whether a junior developer could work from home on Friday. Including which coffee brand to stock in the kitchen.

The CEO knew the CTO was "involved in a lot of decisions." He didn't know it was 89%. He didn't know it was everything.

The Cost Nobody Was Measuring

The CTO was working 72 hours per week. The CEO was working 68. The other four leadership team members were working 45-50 — and spending 30% of their time waiting for decisions.

The company had grown from 12 people to 87 in three years. The decision architecture hadn't grown at all. It was still the same informal system that worked when everyone sat in the same room.

The 30-Day Intervention

Week 1: Decision Audit

We tracked every decision for five days. Not what people said they decided — what they actually decided. The results were shocking:

  • 89% made by the CTO
  • 7% made by the CEO
  • 4% made by the other four leaders combined

Week 2: Decision Rights Matrix

We built a one-page matrix with three columns:

  • Decide: These decisions belong to this person alone
  • Consult: This person must be consulted before the decision is made
  • Inform: This person must be informed after the decision is made

It took six hours to build. It eliminated 60% of the CTO's decision load immediately.

Week 3: Escalation Protocol

We defined three escalation rules:

  1. 1.If a decision sits unmade for 24 hours, it escalates
  2. 2.If two people disagree on who decides, it goes to the matrix
  3. 3.If the matrix doesn't cover it, the CEO decides in 48 hours

Week 4: Decision Log

Every decision made under the new system is logged with: what, who, when, and why. This isn't bureaucracy — it's how you learn which decisions you're still making that you shouldn't be.

The Results

  • CTO's decision load dropped from 89% to 34%
  • CEO's decision load increased from 7% to 23% (strategic decisions only)
  • The other four leaders' combined load increased from 4% to 43%
  • CTO's work week dropped from 72 hours to 51
  • CEO's work week dropped from 68 to 46
  • Average decision speed increased by 3x

The Founder Bandwidth Recovery

The CEO got 22 hours per week back. Not by working less — by deciding differently.

Those 22 hours went into:

  • Two new strategic partnerships (signed in 60 days)
  • A product line expansion that added $4M in pipeline
  • Actually taking weekends off for the first time in two years

The Lesson

Decision concentration is a scaling killer. When one person makes most decisions, you don't have a leadership team — you have a bottleneck with a title.

The fix isn't delegation training. It's decision architecture. And it starts with knowing what you're actually deciding.

Founder ConstraintCase StudyDecision Rights